Section 2.4

Graphical Misrepresentations

Don't be fooled by the visual lie. Learn to spot deceptive data practices like truncated axes, misleading scales, and the 3D pictograph trap.

1

The Truncated Axis (Non-Zero Origin)

The Deception

Starting the vertical axis at a value other than zero. This exaggerates differences between groups, making small changes look massive.

"Interest rates skyrocketed!" (When they actually went from 3.1% to 3.2% but the graph started at 3.0%)
Comparison of Misleading Truncated Axis vs Honest Graph
Misleading (Left) vs. Honest (Right)
2

Scaling & Proportions

Comparison of Compressed vs Stretched Trend Scales
Same data, different emotional impact

Manipulating Perception

By stretching or compressing the axes, you can manipulate how a trend is perceived ("panic" vs. "stability").

Compressed Y-Axis

Makes a volatile stock look stable and "safe".

Stretched Y-Axis

Makes a stable growth look like an unstoppable extreme "boom".

3

The Pictograph Problem

3D Objects in 2D Space

Using pictures (like money bags, oil drums, or houses) instead of bars is visually appealing but mathematically deceptive.

LogicLens: The Square-Cube Law

If you double the height of a 3D object to show "double" the data, you also automatically double the width and depth.

Your eye sees 8 times more "stuff", misleading you to think the increase is huge.

Misleading 3D Pictograph Example
The 200 bag looks massive compared to the 100 bag
4

The Honest Graph Checklist

Title

Clearly states what the graph represents.

Labels

Axes are labeled with variables vs units.

Scale

Starts at zero (or is clearly continuous) w/ uniform increments.

Source

Cites where the data came from.

Adaptive Engine

LogicLens Practice Suite

Log in to Access Adaptive Practice